Israel’s Protection Minister Yoav Gallant speaks throughout a ceremony marking the Hebrew calendar anniversary of the Hamas assault on October 7 final 12 months that sparked the continued struggle in Gaza, on the Mount Herzl navy cemetery in Jerusalem, Israel Sunday Oct. 27, 2024.
Gil Cohen-Magen/AP/Pool AFP
cover caption
toggle caption
Gil Cohen-Magen/AP/Pool AFP
On his final day as Israel’s protection minister, Yoav Gallant advised members of the family of the Israeli hostages in Gaza that the Israeli navy had achieved all of its targets in Gaza and that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was chargeable for holding up a ceasefire deal that might finish the struggle and get the remaining hostages house.
Netanyahu fired Gallant final week, saying that belief between them had “eroded” and that “vital variations” had emerged between himself and Gallant about easy methods to proceed within the struggle in Gaza.
Gil Dickmann was one of many members of the family on the assembly with Gallant on Thursday. “I felt like he was lastly free to talk freely and to say what he thinks,” Dickmann advised NPR.
Gallant, who served as protection minister for everything of the struggle till now, advised them that there was a deal on the desk in July that might have introduced the hostages house in two phases – Gallant mentioned he urged Netanyahu to simply accept the deal however that the prime minister refused.
It was heartbreaking for Dickmann to listen to. His cousin, Carmel Gat, was 39 when she was taken hostage – together with about 250 others – final October 7, within the Hamas-led assault on Israel that killed round 1,200 individuals.
After Netanyahu mentioned no to the attainable ceasefire deal in July, Gat was killed in Gaza together with 5 different Israeli hostages in August. Hamas later took accountability for his or her killings.
Since July, 1000’s extra Palestinians have been killed by the Israeli navy in Gaza – bringing the loss of life toll as much as greater than 43,000 in response to the ministry of well being – and several other extra hostages have been confirmed useless as effectively.
A protester holds an Israeli flag as Israelis gentle a bonfire throughout a protest after Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has dismissed his protection minister Yoav Gallant in a shock announcement in Tel Aviv, Israel, Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2024.
Francisco Seco/AP/AP
cover caption
toggle caption
Francisco Seco/AP/AP
“It was very clear from him that the explanation why we did not take this deal was not navy, it wasn’t diplomatic – I feel it was a political purpose,” Dickmann mentioned, referring to Netanyahu utilizing it for his personal political acquire “That meant that my cousin, who was alive originally of July, stayed in captivity and was murdered simply six weeks later.”
Dickmann says Gallant advised them that the Israeli navy has now achieved all it will possibly in Gaza.
“What he mentioned is there’s solely a lot you are able to do with power, and so they’ve finished it,” he recalled.
Dickmann paraphrased Gallant’s phrases to them: “‘We have no extra rivals, any extra enemies that we are able to even kill proper now, as a result of they’re all useless. We killed all of them.’ Because the Minister of Protection, he mentioned, ‘I did my job’.” Gallant was referring to a sequence of excessive degree Hamas leaders who’ve been killed by the Israeli navy, together with chief Yahya Sinwar in October.
NPR obtained a transcript and listened to a recording of the assembly with Gallant and was in a position to confirm what Gil Dickmann advised us.
NPR additionally reached out to each Gallant and the Prime Minister’s workplace about these claims. Neither responded.
For Dickmann, listening to that Netanyahu has been the primary sticking level in negotiations was form of a aid. “It looks like we have been by means of 13 months of gaslighting during which Netanyahu is telling us ‘No, this isn’t my fault, […] don’t blame me for the truth that the hostages aren’t right here’,” Dickmann mentioned.
Gallant’s ouster is the most recent in a sequence of personnel strikes Netanyahu has revamped the struggle in Gaza. In June, Netanyahu dissolved his struggle cupboard, which gave him extra unilateral management over the struggle.
The Worldwide Prison Courtroom is looking for arrest warrants for each Netanyahu and Gallant for struggle crimes associated to Gaza.
Gallant’s firing, in response to an Israeli official who spoke on the situation of anonymity to debate inside deliberations, was introduced on the day of the U.S. presidential election as a result of the Biden administration can be in any other case distracted and wouldn’t have the ability to protest the choice.
But it surely didn’t cease the Israeli public from protesting throughout the nation, shutting down main highways, lighting fires and ultimately being quelled by police. Many noticed this as another transfer towards the breakdown of Israel’s democracy.
“We really feel that our nation is slipping away, and tonight is simply the final nail on the coffin,” mentioned 37-year-old Maayan Oz, at protests in Tel Aviv. “It is the final proof that the Prime Minister determined that his personal pursuits are extra vital than the safety and the lifetime of the citizen.”
Efforts to get ceasefire talks restarted have been sluggish transferring. In the meantime, dozens of Palestinians proceed to be killed by Israeli strikes daily in Gaza, and 101 Israeli hostages – round a 3rd of whom are confirmed useless – proceed to languish in captivity.
NPR’s Daniel Estrin contributed to this report.
